But in practise, you need to specify what sortedness means, and in a generic sorting algorithm that means axiomatising the comparison predicate, including its side-effects. Note for example the C standard library implementation of Quicksort does take an arbitrary predicate, which may not be transitive, may have arbitrary side effects etc. The behaviour of sorting becomes pretty complicated in this scenario.
But in practise, you need to specify what sortedness means, and in a generic sorting algorithm that means axiomatising the comparison predicate, including its side-effects. Note for example the C standard library implementation of Quicksort does take an arbitrary predicate, which may not be transitive, may have arbitrary side effects etc. The behaviour of sorting becomes pretty complicated in this scenario.