Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> look at the results of your search queries. See any spam?

Not in my queries, no.



I'll bet you don't even realize it's spam. Do a search for something like 'water heater reviews' and several of those links on the front page will ultimately send you to an affiliate site or zip submit. Spam.


> I'll bet you don't even realize it's spam.

This is so condescending it's amazing. You're calling me an idiot, you know that, right?


@silverbax88 - exactly!

No matter how well designed or "active" websites may appear, if its only function is to send you to some affiliate offer - it's spam. The best of them are very good at faking legit websites (even having an active "community" engaged in "discussion"). They are extremely good at faking normal human activity and I don't see the end to it. There's virtually nothing you can do that a script can't do also.


>if its only function is to send you to some affiliate offer - it's spam //

I don't think this definition is quite right.

A site can be good and still have as its raison d'etre referring you to a product manufacturer. After all any sales website is doing the same thing, there's just a certain distance between affiliate sites and the manufacturer.

Don't get me wrong, a lot of affiliate sites are bogus, unhelpful and given unwarranted prevalence in SERPs; but that doesn't make them all bad. For example in the UK there are sites that offer money back on all purchases - they're affiliate sites that share the affiliate fee with the purchaser.


Monetizing your website with affiliate offers doesn't make it spam. Having no other purpose than to redirect a visitor to an offer - does. Especially if you use less than lilly white SEO techniques. Here's a nice way to put it:

Google believes that pure affiliate websites do not provide additional value for web users, especially if they are part of a program that distributes its content to several hundred affiliates. Because a search result could return multiple sites, all with the same content, they create a frustrating user experience.

And here's the rest of it: http://bit.ly/KWS1cz

>For example in the UK there are sites that offer money back on all purchases

I don't see the relevance.


>I don't see the relevance. //

The only purpose of those sites is to get you to follow affiliate links.

Were you trying to refer to some sort of passthrough short-linking system or something?


I was about to say the same thing. I haven't noticed any spam in my Google search results for a while. If anything, there's less now than there used to be.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: